How It All Started
In December 2013, I launched Bioplastics News. I wanted to understand how the oil, chemicals, and plastics industries operate, especially their technologies, environmental claims, corporate practices, and relationships with European institutions.
What started as a personal publishing project gradually became a platform for criticism, investigation, and satire. Over the years, I have written about corporate scandals, competition disputes, environmental controversies, and the influence of industry lobbying on European policies.
I also developed my own satirical style, using fictional characters, sarcasm, and provocative commentary to question powerful organizations. Eventually, some of those organizations took legal action against me.
Three Legal Proceedings
I am facing separate legal proceedings involving two Italian companies and a European Commission official. These are distinct cases. The damages discussed below are amounts claimed, not damages awarded by a court.
1. ENI — €2.1 Million
ENI, the Italian multinational energy company, has brought civil proceedings against me in Rome, seeking €2.1 million in damages. The dispute concerns reporting and commentary published on Bioplastics News.
I believe the financial scale of the claim raises important questions about proportionality and freedom of expression.
2. Novamont — €1.05 Million
Novamont, the Italian bioplastics company owned by ENI through Versalis, has brought separate proceedings in Novara, seeking €1.05 million. My reporting has examined Novamont’s business, industry relationships, environmental claims, and competition-law developments.
Together, ENI and Novamont are claiming €3.15 million.
3. European Commission Official — Belgium
I am also involved in separate civil proceedings initiated in Belgium by an official working at the European Commission’s Directorate-General for Competition (DG COMP). The action was brought by the individual official, not formally by the European Commission as an institution.
Nevertheless, the situation raises questions for me about freedom of expression, public accountability, and how European institutions respond when officials become involved in litigation connected to public commentary.
Timeline of the Dispute
| Date | Development |
|---|---|
| December 2013 | Launch of Bioplastics News |
| June 2025 | Italian competition authority fines Novamont approximately €32 million for abuse of dominance |
| August 2025 | First legal correspondence concerning ENI and Novamont |
| December 2025 | Mediation proceedings in Italy |
| April 2026 | Italian administrative court confirms the competition authority’s decision against Novamont |
| July 2026 | Response received from the European Commission concerning my anti-SLAPP concerns |
| October 2026 | I publicly report approximately €15,000 in legal expenses |
| December 2026 | Scheduled procedural steps in Rome |
| March 2027 | Scheduled hearing in Novara |
Future hearing dates may change. This timeline distinguishes completed events from scheduled procedural steps.
What Did I Actually Write?
Much of my writing uses satire. I created a fictional character named Eni Versalis, who appears in exaggerated stories about corporate behavior, industry lobbying, and European institutions. My satirical commentary sometimes uses deliberately provocative language and historical comparisons.
I recognize that satire can be controversial, uncomfortable, or offensive. However, I believe it plays an important role in public debate. Readers should distinguish factual reporting, allegations, opinions, and fictional commentary. The original passages and supporting links remain accessible in the archive below.
The Industry Boycott
Before these lawsuits, I had already experienced what I consider significant pressure from parts of the bioplastics industry. One important dispute concerned oxo-degradable plastics, industry lobbying, and the actions of European Bioplastics.
I believe that broader history is relevant to how my relationship with the industry deteriorated. Read the industry boycott documentation.
My Attempts to Resolve the Dispute
I have repeatedly expressed a willingness to review specific disputed publications and consider corrections where justified. I have also requested precise identification of webpages, URLs, and passages at issue.
My position has been that dialogue, correction, and clarification should be considered before escalating disagreements into lengthy and expensive legal proceedings. I remain willing to address genuine factual mistakes.
The Financial Consequences
Defending myself in Belgium and Italy has required substantial time and resources. As of October 2026, my reported legal costs had reached approximately €15,000.
For an independent publisher, even the cost of defending a claim can become a significant burden, regardless of the eventual outcome. Read my account of the legal costs.
Why I Believe This Raises Anti-SLAPP Concerns
SLAPP stands for Strategic Lawsuit Against Public Participation. I believe aspects of these proceedings raise concerns about the disproportionate use of litigation against people participating in public debate. Whether a particular case legally qualifies as a SLAPP is ultimately a matter for the competent courts.
What happens to independent journalism when the potential financial consequences of criticism become so overwhelming that publishers cannot afford to defend themselves?
My Position
I do not expect companies or institutions to agree with everything I publish. I understand that criticism and satire can provoke disagreement. But I believe disputes over public-interest reporting should be addressed proportionately, with respect for freedom of expression and the right to criticize powerful organizations.
I am not asking to be above the law. I am asking that the law not become an instrument that makes independent criticism financially impossible.
This website documents the proceedings, my perspective, and supporting material so readers can examine the evidence and reach their own conclusions.
Documents, Original Articles & Further Reading
Find background information on the Novamont case, SLAPPs and press freedom, resources and documents, and industry investigations. The original articles, external links, satirical passages, and documentation from this page are retained in full below for reference.
